| Pos |
Player |
NFL |
YFFL |
| K | Badgley, Mike | WAS | Orangutangs |
| K | Bullock, Randy | - | Buddies |
| K | Carlson, Daniel | LV | Brothers |
| K | Crosby, Mason | - | Llamas |
| K | Dicker, Cameron | LAC | Mallards |
| K | Elliott, Jake | PHI | Thugs |
| K | Folk, Nick | NE | Dragons |
| K | Gould, Robbie | - | Poop |
| K | Hopkins, Dustin | LAC | Mallards |
| K | Lutz, Will | NO | Mallards |
| K | Maher, Brett | DEN | Thugs |
| K | McLaughlin, Chase | TB | Brothers |
| K | Myers, Jason | SEA | Beans |
| K | Patterson, Riley | DET | Eaters |
| K | Pineiro, Eddy | CAR | White Guys |
| K | Prater, Matt | ARZ | Beans |
| K | Sanders, Jason | MIA | Dragons |
| K | Santos, Cairo | CHI | Chickens |
| K | Slye, Joey | WAS | Eaters |
| K | Succop, Ryan | - | Chickens |
| K | Wright, Matthew | - | Merry Men |
| K | York, Cade | CLE | Boys |
| QB | Brady, Tom | - | Poop |
| QB | Brissett, Jacoby | WAS | Orangutangs |
| QB | Dalton, Andy | CAR | Huskers |
| QB | Darnold, Sam | SF | Merry Men |
| QB | Ehlinger, Sam | IND | Dragons |
| QB | Heinicke, Taylor | ATL | Poop |
| QB | Huntley, Tyler | BAL | Mallards |
| QB | Mayfield, Baker | TB | Buddies |
| QB | Mills, Davis | HOU | Refugees |
| QB | Perkins, Bryce | - | Boys |
| QB | Ryan, Matt | - | Dragons |
| QB | Wentz, Carson | - | Huskers |
| QB | White, Mike | MIA | Refugees |
| QB | Willis, Malik | TEN | Buddies |
| QB | Winston, Jameis | NO | Thugs |
| QB | Wolford, John | TB | White Guys |
| QB | Zappe, Bailey | NE | Mallards |
| RB | Boone, Mike | HOU | Llamas |
| RB | Davis-Price, Tyrion | SF | Chickens |
| RB | Drake, Kenyan | IND | Boys |
| RB | Gordon III, Melvin | BAL | Chickens |
| RB | Harris, Damien | BUF | White Guys |
| RB | Haskins, Hassan | TEN | Chickens |
| RB | Hasty, JaMycal | JAX | Orangutangs |
| RB | Henderson, Darrell | - | Beans |
| RB | Hines, Nyheim | BUF | Merry Men |
| RB | Hunt, Kareem | - | White Guys |
| RB | Huntley, Caleb | - | Orangutangs |
| RB | Knight, Zonovan | NYJ | Huskers |
| RB | Moss, Zack | IND | Brothers |
| RB | Murray, Latavius | BUF | Poop |
| RB | Patterson, Cordarrelle | ATL | Beans |
| RB | Robinson, James | NYG | Brothers |
| TE | Bellinger, Daniel | NYG | Eaters |
| TE | Bryant, Harrison | CLE | White Guys |
| TE | Conklin, Tyler | NYJ | Llamas |
| TE | Dissly, Will | SEA | Thugs |
| TE | Everett, Gerald | LAC | Boys |
| TE | Hooper, Austin | LV | Beans |
| TE | Likely, Isaiah | BAL | Buddies |
| TE | Moreau, Foster | NO | Orangutangs |
| TE | Otton, Cade | TB | Huskers |
| TE | Smith, Jonnu | ATL | Brothers |
| TE | Smith Jr., Irv | CIN | Brothers |
| TE | Tonyan, Robert | CHI | Eaters |
| TE | Tremble, Tommy | CAR | Refugees |
| TE | Wright, Brock | DET | Buddies |
| WR | Anderson, Robbie | ARZ | Boys |
| WR | Bell, David | CLE | Refugees |
| WR | Berrios, Braxton | MIA | Refugees |
| WR | Bourne, Kendrick | NE | White Guys |
| WR | Carter, DeAndre | LV | Merry Men |
| WR | Claypool, Chase | CHI | Buddies |
| WR | Davis, Corey | NYJ | Chickens |
| WR | Dortch, Greg | ARZ | Thugs |
| WR | Duvernay, Devin | BAL | Thugs |
| WR | Gage, Russell | TB | Eaters |
| WR | Hamler, K.J. | - | Beans |
| WR | Hollins, Mack | ATL | Poop |
| WR | Jefferson, Van | LAR | Boys |
| WR | Jones, Julio | - | Poop |
| WR | Jones Jr., Marvin | DET | Dragons |
| WR | Jones Jr., Velus | CHI | Refugees |
| WR | Landry, Jarvis | - | Llamas |
| WR | McKenzie, Isaiah | IND | Llamas |
| WR | Osborn, K.J. | MIN | Buddies |
| WR | Palmer, Joshua | LAC | Boys |
| WR | Patrick, Tim | DEN | Merry Men |
| WR | Peoples-Jones, Donovan | CLE | Beans |
| WR | Robinson, Demarcus | LAR | Thugs |
| WR | Samuel, Curtis | WAS | White Guys |
| WR | Shaheed, Rashid | NO | Brothers |
| WR | Shakir, Khalil | BUF | Merry Men |
| WR | Shenault Jr., Laviska | CAR | Orangutangs |
| WR | Skowronek, Ben | LAR | Poop |
| WR | Thornton, Tyquan | NE | Eaters |
| WR | Tolbert, Jalen | DAL | Boys |
| WR | Watkins, Quez | PHI | Eaters |
| WR | Woods, Robert | HOU | Merry Men |
| WR | Zaccheaus, Olamide | PHI | Orangutangs |